Myanmar State Security Involved in Human Trafficking of Rohingya Muslims

Responsible for Equality And Liberty (R.E.A.L.) has become aware of a new human rights report on the ongoing human rights crisis of Rohingya Muslims, which indicates that the Myanmar state security forces are “complicit in and profiting from” human trafficking of Rohingya Muslims refugees, seeking to flee from violence and persecution.

On November 7, 2014 the Fortify Rights group reported, “Myanmar state security forces are complicit in and profiting from the increasingly lucrative maritime human trafficking and smuggling of Rohingya Muslims from Myanmar’s Rakhine State, Fortify Rights revealed in a briefing released today. Since 2012, Myanmar state security forces in Rakhine State have collected payments from Rohingya asylum seekers fleeing Myanmar by ships operated by transnational criminal syndicates, according to information obtained by Fortify Rights. In some cases, the Myanmar Navy escorted boats operated by criminal gangs out to international waters.”

“Local Rohingya brokers mostly deliver payments to members of the Lon Thein riot police, Myanmar Police Department, Navy, and Army in amounts ranging from 500,000 kyat ($500 USD) to 600,000 kyat ($600 USD) per shipload of Rohingya asylum seekers in exchange for passage out to sea. In one case documented by Fortify Rights, the Myanmar Navy demanded 7-million kyat ($7,000 USD) from a criminal gang operating a ship filled with Rohingya fleeing to Malaysia. In other cases, members of the Myanmar Police Department took up to 15,000 kyat ($15 USD) per person directly from individual Rohingya passengers.”

“From September 2013 to October 2014, Fortify Rights interviewed more than 90 Rohingya men and women in Myanmar, Thailand, and Malaysia, many of whom fled the country between 2012 and 2014. Thousands more have fled in recent weeks.”

“Tens of thousands of Rohingya in Rakhine State are now preparing to board 50-to-100-person occupancy boats on the western coast of Myanmar. These boats transport Rohingya asylum seekers to larger ships in the Bay of Bengal that hold as many as 1,000 people. The vast majority of Rohingya who depart by sea soon find themselves in the custody of abusive human trafficking and smuggling gangs, who detain them in conditions of enslavement and exploitation.”

“Most Rohingya are fleeing persecution in Myanmar. Before boarding ships, they are generally not fully informed and, in many cases, are deceived about the treatment they will endure, additional costs, and other aspects of the journey to Malaysia. Many are sold multiple times and for a myriad of reasons, including for labor and sexual exploitation. Nearly all endure or witness torture, deprivation of food and water, confinement in extremely close quarters, and other abuses throughout their journey.”

“In 2012, civilians and state security forces razed Muslim villages in 13 of 17 townships in Rakhine State. More than 300,000 people — predominantly Rohingya Muslims — are now in need of humanitarian aid in the state, according to the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Aid. That includes 70,000 ‘food insecure’ people, 50,000 living in isolated villages, 50,000 in ‘host communities,’ and approximately 140,000 Rohingya and non-Rohingya Muslims living in more than 80 internally displaced person (IDP) camps. More than 100,000 Rohingya reportedly fled the country by sea in the last two years. Rakhine Buddhists also endured casualties and displacement in Rakhine State in 2012 on a lesser scale.”

“Scores of Rohingya who were displaced in Rakhine State told Fortify Rights that inadequate food, health care, and livelihood opportunities in the IDP camps as well as restrictions on movement and fear of future persecution contributed to their decision to flee Myanmar.”

“Moreover, more than 1 million Rohingya continue to be directly affected by persecutory state policies restricting their movement, marriage, childbirth, and other aspects of everyday life in Rakhine State. Rohingya who were not displaced by attacks in 2012 but still face persecution told Fortify Rights that they fled the country due to restrictions imposed by the state, including restrictions on freedom of movement, threats of violence, and ongoing pressure to abandon their ethnic identity.”

Fortify Rights’ report calls for action on Myanmar for the Trafficking in Persons (TIP) report by the U.S. Department of State.

“Trafficking in persons is prohibited under international law, and states have a duty to take action to combat trafficking. Human trafficking includes elements of deceit, exploitation, and abuse. Human smuggling, on the other hand, involves a ‘client’ consenting and paying to be transported across an international border.”

“In June 2014, Myanmar maintained its place on the United States Department of State’s tier-two watch list in the annual Trafficking in Persons (TIP) report. Myanmar has remained on the tier-two watch list through a system of waivers. Unless demonstrable changes take place in the next year, the country could be downgraded to tier-three status — the lowest designation reserved for countries failing to adequately combat human trafficking.”

A Rohingya Muslim man who fled Myanmar to Bangladesh to escape religious violence, cries after he and others were intercepted in Taknaf, Bangladesh. (PHOTO AP)
A Rohingya Muslim man who fled Myanmar to Bangladesh to escape religious violence, cries after he and others were intercepted in Taknaf, Bangladesh. (PHOTO AP)

June 8 Media Reports Associated with Gaza Ships

June 8 Media Reports Associated with Gaza Ships

Hamas prevents flotilla aid from entering Gaza

‘Iranian ships won’t reach Gaza’

Israel Gov’t disturbed by Reuters’ cropping of raid photos

Reuters claims removal of knife from hands in cropped photos was “inadvertantly cropped”
Reuters handbook on journalism: “No additions or deletions to the subject matter of the original image. (thus changing the original content and journalistic integrity of an image)”

Israeli Navy officers call on Netanyahu, Barak to establish probe into raid

Jerusalem Post issues petition

UN aid chief calls for end to Gaza blockade

June 7 Media Reports Associated with Gaza Ships

June 7 Media Reports Associated with Gaza Ships

Israel: Known terrorists on flotilla

(Iran/Gaza)  Report: Iran to send ships to Gaza
— Iranian Red Crescent planning two aid ships this week

Iran raises Gaza threat by vowing to challenge Israel’s blockade

Turkey calls on Israel to accept probe into raid

(Turkey) Today’s Zaman: “IHH responds to Israeli accusations of terrorism”

(Turkey/U.S.) Schumer Wants Probe into Turkish Flotilla’s Terrorist Ties

Diplomats Ponder How To Investigate Events Leading To Deadly Israeli Raid

Daily Telegraph: “IHH releases pictures of bloody Israeli commando after Gaza raid”
— IHH group linked to radical Islam issues photos of injured Israeli soldiers

US Jews to hold flotilla protest

Report: New Ships Headed to Gaza, More Violence Feared

Media reports on additional ships planned to Gaza and possible additional violence

Times of India: New boats headed to Gaza to challenge Israeli blockade— Irish-Malaysian ship MV Rachel Corrie, which is currently off the coast of Libya and due to arrive off Gaza tomorrow

Irish Times: ‘Rachel Corrie’ aims to reach Gaza

Reuters: Activists to take another run at Gaza blockade

Jerusalem Post report of Israel Navy officer: ‘Next time we’ll use more force’
— Israel Navy officer reportedly states
: “we will have to come prepared in the future as if it was a war”

Ship MV Linda Renamed MV Rachel Corrie (Photo: RT)
Ship MV Linda Renamed MV Rachel Corrie (Photo: RT)

June 1 Media Reports Associated with Gaza Ships

June 1 Media Reports Associated with Gaza Ships
UN: Impartial probe of flotilla raid
— Jerusalem Post
: UN Security Council “called for condemnation of the attack by Israeli forces ‘in the strongest terms’ and ‘an independent international investigation.'”
Daily Telegraph: “UN Security Council has called for a prompt and impartial investigation into the Israeli attack against a flotilla carrying humanitarian aid to Gaza, and the immediate release of all civilians”

600 activists held in Beersheba jail

Israel Video of IDF Soldiers Beaten when Boarding Flotilla Ship Mavi Marmara

VOA: Pressure Grows on Israel Following Flotilla Raid

UK: Man charged over Gaza aid ship protest outside BBC

In Asia Protests, Condemnation Follow Israeli Raid on Gaza Flotilla

ABC report: Official: US Will Stand with Israel

London Times report on passenger list:
— Swedish Henning Mankell with eight other Swedes
— former U.S. ambassador to Mauritania Edward Peck
— U.S. television producer David Schermerhorn
— Three German MPs and a Swedish MP
— Britons Peter Venner and Rachel Bridgeland
— Britons Denis Healey, Paveen Yaqub, Kevin Ovenden, Theresa McDermott, Alex Harrison, Baboo Zanghar, Sakir Yildirim
— Irish Paul McGeough, Shane Dillon, Dr Fintan Lane, Fiachra O Luain, “Two naturalised Irish-Libyans and one person of Irish-Polish dual citizenship were also on board”
— “Of the nearly 600 people on the Mavi Marmara ship, roughly 400 were Turkish citizens”
— Turks Mehmet Ali Akdeniz, Demet Tezcan, Şahin İbrahim Güleryüz, Fevzi Çorluk, Abdülahad Abdurrahman, Nilufer Cetin, Kaan Turker, Ekrem Cetin
— Six Greeks
— U.S. Navy veteran Joe Meadors
— Two Australian journalists and two other Australian women

Ynet News reports on Flotilla raid in foreign media

Ynet News reports on Arab media reaction

Daily Telegraph: World press reaction to Gaza aid flotilla

May 31 Media Reports Associated with Gaza Ships

Various media are reporting on violence involving a flotilla of ships in international waters headed towards Gaza described as “aid ships.”  The reports describe Israeli  helicopters and military halting the flotilla in international waters, and soldiers boarding one of the ships in the flotilla, the Turkish Mavi Marmara ship, during which shots were fired.  The IDF reports that the Mavi Marmara ship held “extremists” that sought to attack an Israeli commando who boarded the ship, and took the Israeli commando’s gun away.

The media has had wide ranging reports on the casualties and the causes from 10 to 20 killed, and 60 injured, including injured Israel soldiers.  Reports on the tolls include: RT video has reportedTurkey’s NTV states, and The Daily Telegraph.

The Israel Defense Force (IDF) released video reportedly of soldiers being beaten when trying to board the ship.

BBC reports that Israel’s Deputy Foreign Minister “Danny Ayalon said it was a ‘premeditated and outrageous provocation’ and the activists on board were intent on violence;” Ayalon described the flotilla as an “armada  of hate and violence in support of Hamas organization was a premeditated and outrageous provocation. The organizers are well-known to their ties to global Violent Extemism, Al-Qaeda, and Hamas…”

A Turkish news agency reported that X-ray of items brought on board the ship showed no weapons. In media reports, the Israel government claims that violence only occurred on the ship Mavi Marmara.

United Nations’ human rights chief Navi Pillay said she was “shocked” at the violence.  United Nations Secretary General Ban stated: “I am shocked by reports of killings and injuries of people on boats carrying supplies for Gaza… “I condemn this violence… It is vital that there is a full investigation to determine exactly how this bloodshed took place.”

The Associated Press reported that the U.S. President Obama administration spokesman Bill Burton stated that it “deeply regrets the loss of life and injuries sustained” and that U.S. administration officials are “currently working to understand the circumstances surrounding this tragedy.”

Other reports included those of French President Sarkozy stating that he  “condemns the disproportionate use of force and sends his condolences to the families of the victims,” Greece has canceled military exercises with Israel, and the Turkish ambassador to Israel has been withdrawn.  The Turkish NTV/NBC news agency published images of wounded in “handcuffs,” and protesters have been outside the Israeli consulate in Turkey.

One report states that protests are also occurring throughout Israel.

Flotilla Ship Mavi Marmara (Photo: BBC)
Flotilla Ship Mavi Marmara (Photo: BBC)

Media Reports:

RT TV: Gaza Flotilla Attacked: Israeli troops storm aid ships, up to 20 killed

Daily Mail: Israeli commandos kill up to 19 peace activists in raid on ships heading to Gaza

Daily Telegraph: Israeli troops attack ship carrying aid to Gaza killing 16

Jerusalem Post: Barak: Gaza flotilla responsible for 15 activists killed

Jerusalem Post: Ashkenazi: Only 1 of 6 ships in flotilla carried extremists

Jerusalem Post: Israel Navy escorts flotilla ships to Ashdod

Haaretz: Israel tows Gaza aid ships to Ashdod after 10 activists killed in clashes with navy

BBC: Activists ‘never imagined confrontation’

BBC: Deaths as Israeli forces storm Gaza aid ship

BBC: In pictures: Israeli forces storm Gaza aid ship

BBC: Israel: Gaza ship is ‘outrageous provocation’

YouTube Video of IDF Warning to Flotilla

YouTube IDF video reportedly of soldiers being beaten when trying to board the ship

Israeli military gives version of flotilla incident

CNN: Latest developments: Raids in Gaza

Turkey NTV News Web Site

Turkey NTV MSNBC News

Israel minister sees ‘scandal’ over ship killings

Analysis: A race to contain the damage

Gaza Flotilla Organizers Protest Israeli Response to Their Mission

France President Sarkozy: Use of force ‘disproportionate’

Turkey condemns Israel over deadly attack on Gaza aid flotilla

Turkey withdraws ambassador to Israel over deaths
CNN report

Turkey: Protesters in Turkey protested outside of the Israeli consulate

Counter Terrorism Bureau Issues Turkey Travel Warning

Abbas slams ‘slaughter’ at sea

Pakistan condemns Israeli attack on mission

World reaction to Israel’s pre-dawn raid

World in shock at deadly Gaza ship raid

Strong int’l backlash to flotilla raid

UN chief ‘shocked’ by Gaza aid flotilla raid

Gaza flotilla deaths aftermath : Protests erupt all over in Israel.

Australia Broadcasting News: Convoy raid condemned as Aussies found safe

Flotilla’s deadly last moments

Sky News: Flotilla Fiasco: A Cack-Handed Operation

Netanyahu cancels upcoming meeting with Obama
Meeting Between Obama and Netanyahu Off, Israeli Official Says

VOA: UN Security Council Discusses Israeli Raid on Aid Flotilla

Commentary suggests Flotilla interception will empower Hamas:
— Flotilla interception looks like a disastrous own goal for Israel

Thousands protest flotilla deaths

Paris clashes near Israeli Embassy, tear gas used

Gaza: ‘day of rage’ in former holiday haven?