Communist China: Rights Activist Liu Xiaobo Loses Appeal, US and EU Urge Release

The media has reported that China freedom activist Liu Xiaobo has lost his appeal against his 11 year sentence, and that the U.S. government and the European Union have urged for his release.

The Voice of America reports that:
— “China’s High Court Thursday rejected Liu Xiaobo’s appeal to change an 11-year jail sentence, which was handed down on December 25.”
— “The 54-year-old writer was convicted of subversion for helping organize a manifesto called “Charter 08,” which calls for sweeping civil and political reforms. He was detained in December 2008, shortly before the document was released on-line.”
— “The U.S. Ambassador to China Jon Huntsman immediately issued a statement expressing Washington’s disappointment in the decision. The statement, read by Embassy spokesman Richard Buangan, called on the government to release Liu immediately and allow Chinese citizens to peacefully express their political views.”
— ” ‘Persecution of individuals for the peaceful expression of political views is inconsistent with internationally recognized norms of human rights,’ he said.”
— “The European Union also issued a statement calling for Liu’s release and an end to harassment and detention of many of the thousands of Chinese who signed Charter 08.”
The Christian Science Monitor reports that:
— “Liu appealed a sentence, handed down on Dec. 25, that shocked relatives and rights activists with its harshness. It was the heaviest punishment for such a crime that lawyers could remember.”
— “‘His harsh sentence is a stark reminder to the Chinese people and the world that there is still no freedom of expression or independent judiciary in China,” says Roseann Rife, a Hong Kong-based researcher for Amnesty International.”
— “Liu, a scholar and literary critic, was charged with ‘incitement to subversion’ because he coauthored Charter 08, a petition for political freedom and an end to the ruling Communist party’s monopoly of power. The online petition has garnered thousands of signatures since it was released just over a year ago.”
— ” ‘This is a really, really difficult time for human rights in China right now,’ says John Kamm, who heads the US-based human rights group Dui Hua.”

Liu Xiaobo, Chinese Human Rights Activist, Arrested December 8, 2008
Liu Xiaobo, Chinese Human Rights Activist, Arrested December 8, 2008

Other R.E.A.L. Postings on Liu Xiaobo

Communist China Sentences Liu Xiaobo to 11 years in Prison on Christmas Day

Communist China: China dissident begins second year in detention – Liu Xiaobo

Twitter Campaign to Free Chinese Human Rights Advocate Liu Xiaobo

China Support Network publishes letter to Obama re: China trip upcoming this month

Chinese intellectuals speak up for dissident Liu Xiaobo

Communist China accuses pro-democracy activist Liu Xiabo of inciting a rebellion

Communist China: Dissident writer Liu Xiaobo held after sentence ends

Communist China: Arrested Chinese dissident Liu Xiaobo to receive prestigious award

China Charter 08 — December 10, 2008

R.E.A.L. Reports on China

R.E.A.L. Reports on Totalitarianism

Hong Kong Citizens Rally to ‘Protect Shen Yun, Protect Hong Kong’

Hong Kong Citizens Rally to ‘Protect Shen Yun, Protect Hong Kong’
— Epoch Times reports:
“Nearly a thousand people chanted ‘Protect Shen Yun, Protect Hong Kong’ during a rally and parade at Edinburgh Place on Jan. 31. Participants included residents, artists, and current and former Hong Kong legislators who gathered to voice their concern that ‘one country, two systems’ was called into question by events that caused the cancellation of Shen Yun performances in Hong Kong.”

See the rest of the report here

D.C. Rally: Allow Shen Yun Shows to Go On in Hong Kong

Chinese Group Protests for Freedom in DC Outside Hong Kong Offices

See other R.E.A.L. postings on Shen Yun

"Protect Shen Yun, Protect Hong Kong" march on Jan 31. (Li Ming/The Epoch Times)
"Protect Shen Yun, Protect Hong Kong" march on Jan 31. (Li Ming/The Epoch Times)

Chinese Group Protests for Freedom in DC Outside Hong Kong Offices

On a bitterly cold day, Chinese Americans and their supporters protested in Washington DC today outside the Hong Kong Economic and Cultural Representative Office (HKECRO).  They called on the Hong Kong immigration authorities to permit the Shen Yun Performing Arts to perform their Chinese cultural music and dance show in Hong Kong.  On Wednesday, January 27 at press conferences at the National Press Club and on Capitol Hill, supporters of the Shen Yun Performing Arts described how the group’s key production staff were denied visas to support the show for sold-out audiences in Hong Kong.

Washington DC: Supporters of the Shen Yun Performing Arts Protesting Outside Hong Kong Office on January 29, 2010
Washington DC: Supporters of the Shen Yun Performing Arts Protesting Outside Hong Kong Office on January 29, 2010

The supporters of the Shen Yun Performing Arts group told of the importance of allowing artistic freedom to permit the show in Hong Kong, which includes traditional Chinese cultural music and dance, as well as stories about modern-day persecution in Communist China of the Falun Dafa and others that seek human freedom.   Falun Dafa supporters stated that the Shen Yun show would provide a message of hope to the Chinese people in Hong Kong through the values of truth, compassion, and tolerance.

Dr.Sen Nieh and other leaders spoke in support of the need for the Hong Kong immigration authorities to grant the visas necessary to allow the Shen Yun Performing Arts show to be seen by the Chinese people in Hong Kong.    Falun Dafa leader Dr. Shan-Tao Lai presented a letter to the Washington DC Hong Kong Economic and Cultural Representative Office with the Falun Dafa request to allow such necessary visas to be granted.  Dr. Lai was accompanied by Responsible for Equality And Liberty (R.E.A.L.)‘s Jeffrey Imm from the protest group. The Falun Dafa letter was accepted by the Hong Kong office.

Dr. Sen Nieh Speaks Outside Hong Kong Economic and Cultural Representative Office Calling for Approval of Visa for Shen Yun Performing Arts
Dr. Sen Nieh Speaks Outside Hong Kong Economic and Cultural Representative Office Calling for Approval of Visa for Shen Yun Performing Arts
Another Shen Yun Performing Arts Supporter Calls for Artistic Freedom in Hong Kong
Another Shen Yun Performing Arts Supporter Calls for Artistic Freedom in Hong Kong

A key message of the Washington DC protesters was to show that they stood as one in solidarity with their brothers and sisters in Hong Kong.

On Sunday, January 31, 2010, supporters of the Shen Yun Performing Arts will hold a “grand march and rally” to protest the Hong Kong immigration department’s denial of the visa to seven key members of Shen Yun that has caused the forced cancellation of seven sold out shows.  Falun Dafa and Shen Yun supporters anticipate global protests around the world to demonstrate their desire to see the Shen Yun Performing Arts have the opportunity to perform in Hong Kong.

Responsible for Equality And Liberty (R.E.A.L.)‘s Jeffrey Imm also spoke at the protest in support of the Shen Yun Performing Arts, stating that such artistic freedom of expression was a vital way of defending our universal human rights.  He called for the Hong Kong authorities to change their decision on banning Shen Yun show staff from traveling to Hong Kong so that they can provide their Chinese cultural show to the Chinese people. He also urged Americans to contact their government officials to address the Hong Kong government on this.  He stated that the values of truth, tolerance, and compassion shown in the Shen Yun performance was a key part of values essential to our universal human rights, and shared respect for one another.  He stated that R.E.A.L.’s motto for the world is “Love Wins.”

Chinese Cultural Performing Arts Urges Americans to “Take a Stand” on Human Rights

On January 27, 2010, the Shen Yun Performing Arts group held a news conference at the National Press Club in Washington DC, regarding the refusal of Hong Kong authorities to allow members of their pro-human rights Chinese cultural show to perform in Hong Kong.   Days before the Shen Yun Performing Arts was scheduled to perform in Hong Kong, visas for their production staff were denied, preventing their production staff with specialized knowledge of how to manage the Shen Yun performance and choreography from entering Hong Kong.  The result of the visa denial was the cancellation of sold-out shows of the Shen Yun performances, affecting 7,700 ticketed audience members.

Shen Yun Performing Arts is a U.S.-based non-profit organization that provides performances of traditional and regional Chinese dance, music, and culture, including recounting both traditional and modern stories of life in China. In addition, its performances includes discussions of values of truth, compassion, and tolerance, Buddhist religion, and Falun Dafa (Falun Gong) practices.  These modern stories told in dance and music, also include references to oppression of the Falun Dafa in Communist China.

Banner of Shen Yun Performing Arts 2010 World Tour
Banner of Shen Yun Performing Arts 2010 World Tour

Questions were raised as to whether Hong Kong’s stated political environment of “one country, two systems” was being eroded by the influence of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) to pressure Hong Kong immigration authorities from preventing Shen Yun Chinese cultural show from being performed in Hong Kong.  Within Communist China, the city of Hong Kong has in the past been an island where free expression was allowed in the vast totalitarian Communist-ruled nation.  However, with the recent efforts to stymie the Shen Yun show from performing in Hong Kong, some believe that things may be changing in Hong Kong.

Washington DC: Shen Yun Press Conference at National Press Club
Washington DC: Shen Yun Press Conference at National Press Club (Photo: Lisa Fan/Epoch Times)

The panel of artists and production staff on Shen Yun Performing Arts each told stories of how their efforts in preparing to share traditional Chinese cultural dance, stories, and values in their planned show in Hong Kong.  The Shen Yun Performing Arts held shows at the Washington DC’s Kennedy Center in recent weeks that were enjoyed by an audience of many thousands of Washingtonians, and was listed among the “Top 10” entertainment choices in a local Washington DC magazine.

Shen Yun submitted their visa application on October 13, 2009 for the January 27, 2010 performance, and was told of the visa denial on January 20, just days before the performance was to start.  On January 21, U.S. Congressman Gus Bilirakis contacted the Hong Kong immigration authorities on behalf of the Shen Yun Performing Arts group. The Hong Kong immigration authorities claimed that the visa denial was to demand that Shen Yun hire a “local production staff” when it is standard for major performances to bring their trained production staff with them to performances, a problem that Shen Yun has not had in performing in over 100 locations around the world in Europe, Asia, and the United States.  Shen Yun Production Manager Gregory Xu explained how knowledge of the specific choreography and aspects of the performance were essential to such a major production, stating that even when Shen Yun submitted supplementary documents explaining the need for such production staff, the Hong Kong authorities ignored their request.  Mr. Xu concluded in frustration that “I can see the black hand of the Communists behind this.”

Panel at Shen Yun Press Conference
Panel at Shen Yun Press Conference (Photo: Lisa Fan/Epoch Times)

Shen Yun performer Cindy Liu spoke as to how shocked she was at the Hong Kong immigration authorities decision.  She expressed how the Shen Yun cultural performance was designed to revive the Chinese culture which has been damaged by the Communist Chinese Party.  Ms. Liu said that one of the goals of the Shen Yun shows were to bring back such traditional Chinese culture of dance, stories, and values back to the Chinese people.  She expressed her concern about the apparent change in tone regarding freedom in Hong Kong, stating that “the freedom in Hong Kong is getting less and less.”  ” If principles such as truth, compassion, and tolerance can be blocked, what else can be blocked?”

Cindy Liu - if Principles of Truth, Compassion, and Tolerance can be blocked by Communists, what will happen to freedom in Hong Kong? (Photo: Epoch Times)
Cindy Liu - if Principles of Truth, Compassion, and Tolerance can be blocked , what will happen to freedom in Hong Kong? (Photo: Lisa Fan/Epoch Times)

Shen Yun danger Hoiwa Lee, a native of Hong Kong, spoke of the disappointment among those she had spoke to in Hong Kong.  She had looked forward to performing for forty of her family and friends.  She had received an email from one friend who was “very shocked that this could happen in Hong Kong.”

Hoiwa Lee Speaks at Shen Yun Press Conference
Hong Kong Native Hoiwa Lee Says that Hong Kong Residents Are "Very Shocked That This Could Happen in Hong Kong" (Photo: Lisa Fan/Epoch Times)

Shen Yun Company Manager and Choreographer Vina Lee stated that she grew up in China and says that you can’t see any traditional Chinese cultural dance and performances there.  Ms. Lee stated that the performers were shocked by the Hong Kong immigration authorities’ decision. But she remained optimistic that Shen Yun will perform in Hong Kong and Communist China mainland someday, stating “We want to bring Chinese culture — truth, compassion and beauty – back to China.”  Vina Lee also pointed out that the Communist Chinese government had previously attempted to disrupt Shen Yun performances in other places, recounting an attempt to influence government officials in Australia.

Vina Lee Speaks at Shen Yun Press Conference
Vina Lee : "We want to bring Chinese culture -- truth, compassion and beauty - back to China." (Photo: Lisa Fan/Epoch Times)

Leeshai Lemish, the emcee of the Shen Yun Performing Arts, spoke of the importance of the Shen Yun show in helping to preserve traditional Chinese culture.  He said that Shen Yun communicated such culture and values through its dance and music, and that the denial of the Hong Kong visa was a “threat to artistic freedom.”     Mr. Lemish stated that such Chinese culture has been destroyed to a large extent by the Chinese Communist Party, first by the Communist “Cultural Revolution” designed to undermine such culture, and then over the years of preventing the Chinese people from celebrating such culture.  A U.S.-Israeli citizen, Mr. Lemish has a college degree in Asian Studies, and spent extended periods conducting research in Asia, and has served as the emcee of the Shen Yun shows since 2006 around the world.  In November 2001, Mr. Lemish was put in jail in Communist China for joining activists in Beijing’s Tiananmen Square for a sit-in meditation underneath a banner with the Falun Dafa principles of “Truth, Compassion, Tolerance.”

Mr. Lemish spoke of other harassment and intimidation tactics regarding Shen Yun performances  by the Communist Chinese government in cities throughout the United States, and in locations around the world, which he has documented on a web site, including performances throughout Europe, Canada, Russia, Australia, Malaysia, Korea, and the United States (New York, Los Angeles, San Diego, Arkansas, Florida).   Regarding a recent Shen Yun tour in Canada, Mr. Lemish also spoke of a recent attack on a Shen Yun show’s bus, where the front tire had been cut in a way, not so that it would go flat, but so that it would burst on the highway while en route.

Leeshai Lemish Speaks at Shen Yun Press Conference
Leeshai Lemish Speaks of "Threat to Artistic Freedom" in Blocking Shen Yun's Show on Traditional Cultural Dance , Music, and Values (Photo: Lisa Fan/Epoch Times)

Washington DC’s Shen Yun dancer Leon Chao urged the American people to pay attention to acts by the Hong Kong immigration authorities to effectively block the performance of the Shen Yun show; Leon Chao is a principal dancer in the show.  Mr. Chao stated that the Hong Kong show is a “very important first step” in ultimately Shen Yun performing in mainland China to allow the Chinese people to see the traditional Chinese culture and values incorporated in the dance and music by Shen Yun Performing Arts.  It was because this show is so important to the Chinese people, that the Shen Yun performers had been rehearsing for many months, he stated.  Leon Chao urged the Hong Kong authorities to give the Shen Yun Performing Arts a chance to perform in Hong Kong as soon as possible.

As a fellow American concerned about the ability to suppress an artistic message of tolerance, compassion, and truth, Leon Chao urged the American people “to take a stand and not take our freedoms for granted.”

Leon Chao Speaks
Washington DC's Leon Chao to Americans: "I ask Americans to take a stand and not take our freedoms for granted"

After the press conference at the National Press Club, there was a follow-up press conference on Capitol Hill at the House Cannon Office Building in the afternoon, which was attended by Congressman Joseph Cao and Gus Bilirakis.

House-Meeting-1 House-Meeting-2

Responsible for Equality And Liberty (R.E.A.L.) urges Americans to contact their government officials to urge them to ask the Hong Kong authorities to change their decision on banning Shen Yun show staff from traveling to Hong Kong so that they can provide their Chinese cultural show to the Chinese people.

Hong Kong: Demonstrators held a press conference outside the Immigration Department (Photo Source: Voice of America, REN Jing-Yang)
Hong Kong: Demonstrators held a press conference outside the Immigration Department (Photo Source: Voice of America, REN Jing-Yang)

We note that the Voice of America is reporting on protests by the Hong Kong people regarding the decision of the Hong Kong immigration authorities preventing the Shen Yun show.  Americans and those people who support freedom around the world should support the efforts of the Hong Kong protesters and those who seek truth, tolerance, and compassion around the world.

We believe that Love Wins.

love-wins-lg

Resources and Reports:

Shen Yun Performing Arts

Handout of Shen Yun Artists and Representatives at Press Conference

Falun Dafa

January 28, 2010 – R.E.A.L.: Chinese Cultural Performing Arts Urges Americans to “Take a Stand” on Human Rights

January 28, 2010 – DC Human Rights Examiner: Suspicion surrounds forced cancellation of Shen Yun’s Hong Kong shows

January 28, 2010 – Epoch Times: Congressmen Object to Hong Kong Action Against Shen Yun

January 27, 2010 – Congressman Rohrabacher’s Statement – Hong Kong Follows Lead of Beijing Overlords by Denying Artists’ Visas

January 26, 2010 – Press Release: Hong Kong Authorities Deny Visas to US-based Shen Yun Performing Arts, Force Cancellation of Sold-Out Shows

January 25, 2010 – Radio Free Asia: Shen Yun Performing Arts Denied Entry Visa to Hong Kong (Chinese)

January 25, 2010 – Radio Free Asia: Shen Yun Performing Arts Denied Entry Visa to Hong Kong – (NDTV Translation into English) page 1

January 25, 2010 – Radio Free Asia: Shen Yun Performing Arts Denied Entry Visa to Hong Kong – (NDTV Translation into English) page 2

January 24, 2010 – Epoch Times: Shen Yun Shows in Hong Kong Canceled Due to Visa Refusal

January 23, 2010 – Voice of America Report on Shen Yun Cancellation (Chinese)

January 23, 2010 – Voice of America Report on Shen Yun Cancellation (NDTV Translation into English) – page 1

January 23, 2010 – Voice of America Report on Shen Yun Cancellation (NDTV Translation into English) – page 2

January 23, 2010 – Voice of America Report on Shen Yun Cancellation (Online Google Translation into English – Imperfect)

January 20, 2010 – Letter from U.S. Congressman Gus Bilirakis to the Hong Kong immigration authorities

January 15, 2010 – Responsible for Equality And Liberty (R.E.A.L.): Shen Yun: Performing for Human Rights and Freedom in China

Evidence of Harrassment of Shen Yun Performing Arts

Video of Shen Yun Performing Arts Audience Reactions

R.E.A.L. – What You Can Do – Contacting Your Government

January 8, 2010 – Communist China’s Influence on U.S. Congress Growing

December 12, 2009 – News Reports on Falun Gong at DC Press Conference

December 12, 2009 – Epoch Times: “International Human Rights Day – Comments Made At National Press Club”

December 10, 2009 – Video of Falun Gong Comments at Human Rights Day Press Conference
– Lisa Tao and Pang Jin – Online Video – Part 1
– Lisa Tao and Pang Jin – Online Video – Part 2
– Lisa Tao and Pang Jin – Online Video – Part 3

– Lisa Tao Human Rights Day Remarks:
— Microsoft Word format (English)
— Microsoft Word format (Chinese)

December 10, 2009 – NDTV Video Report on Human Rights Day (Chinese)

December 10, 2009 – Epoch Times Report on Human Rights Day (Chinese)

December 10, 2009 – DC Human Rights Examiner: Protection of religious minorities is major theme of 2009 Human Rights Day News Conference

R.E.A.L. Postings on Totalitarianism

October 7, 2009 – Epoch Times: Falun Gong Practitioner Dies From Persecution in Beijing

October 4, 2009 – Epoch Times: Mass Arrests of Falun Gong Prior to Communist Anniversary

R.E.A.L.: September 30: Human Rights Protest at Washington DC PRC Embassy

“A Providential Coincidence in Modern Chinese History: The Falun Gong and CDP” By Timothy Cooper, Executive Director, Worldrights

August 31, 2009 – Epoch Times: Lawyer Tortured for Defending Falun Gong Clients

July 20, 2009 – Epoch Times: Falun Gong Suffers a Decade of Terror in China

July 19, 2009 – Epoch Times: Falun Gong and the Freedom of China

July 19: DC Rally for Freedom in China and Freedom for Falun Gong

Full text of July 19 speech by CSN’s John Kusumi – Communist Party creates problems faster than it resolves them

Falun Gong: Candles of Hope
– DC report of protest – PDF file – page 1
– DC report of protest – PDF file – page 2
– DC report of protest – PDF file – page 3

July 15, 2009 – Epoch Times: The Persecution of Falun Gong and How it Began

June 4, 2009 – R.E.A.L.: DC: China Embassy – Responsible for Equality And Liberty Challenges Chinese Govt

June 4, 2009 – R.E.A.L.: DC: Capitol Hill Rally Remembers Tiananmen Martyrs

May 31, 2009 – R.E.A.L.: Washington DC: Many Attend Candlelight Memorial Remembering Tiananmen Square Martyrs

R.E.A.L.: Chinese People Are Human Beings – by Jeffrey Imm

R.E.A.L.: To Defy Hate All You Need is Love – by Jeffrey Imm

Communist China Defends Internet Censorship, Rebukes U.S. Calls for Hacker Investigation

Communist China says Internet controls here to stay

Communist China Ups the Ante in Internet Row With U.S.
— WSJ
: “China stepped up its verbal feud with the U.S. over the Internet, with a commentator in the Communist Party’s main newspaper saying America is seeking to control the Internet and alleging that the U.S. used the Web to incite election protests in Iran last year”

Communist China Rebukes U.S. Calls to Investigate Hacking
— NYT:
“China delivered a bristling response on Monday to the United States’ demand that it investigate recent attacks on American computers from Chinese soil, saying that any suggestion that it conducted or condoned the hackers’ intrusions was ‘groundless and aims to denigrate China.'”